- Does this playbook really apply to me, or is it just for big corporations?
- What did the company that multiplied qualified leads by 9 actually do?
- Why do automated emails work so much better than manual ones?
- What does it mean in practice for an Italian company that wants to replicate it?
- Three real-world scenarios: what could it be worth to an Italian company?
- Which tools do you need, and how do they compare?
- Why it's in the spotlight now: is the Italian market really changing?
- Where do you actually start, step by step?
- What are the most common mistakes that block results?
- How do you know if it's really working?
- So, is marketing automation worth investing in for your company?
- How we see it at SHM
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Automated emails generate 30% of email revenue while accounting for only 2% of total sends: the return per send is about 16 times higher than manual campaigns (Omnisend via Sender.net).
- Precise segmentation is the real engine: in Italy, small, well-profiled segments produce up to 4 times more engagement than mass sends (Magnews Dossier 2025).
- 68% of Italian B2B SMEs have a lead generation problem, but only 8% of large companies have automation at scale: the gap is a real opportunity (Osservatorio Politecnico di Milano).
A marketing team on a limited budget took qualified leads from 12 to 108 a month without increasing ad spend. The secret wasn't spending more: it was to stop sending the wrong emails to the wrong people at the wrong time.
Does this playbook really apply to me, or is it just for big corporations?
It applies to anyone with a contact list, a CRM and at least one active email flow. The case described by HubSpot comes from a secondary market with limited resources: exactly the situation of an Italian SME.
When people talk about marketing automation, meaning systems that send automatic messages based on contact behavior, many business owners immediately think of big budgets and dedicated teams. The reality is different.
The playbook analyzed by HubSpot starts from a common situation: a company in a non-primary market, with few inbound leads and no room to increase spend. The solution was to work better with the contacts it already had, not to look for new ones.
This is exactly the problem the Marketing and ADV performance cluster tackles today: how to get more results from the same investments, without wasting budget on audiences that aren't ready to buy.
| Your situation | Is it worth applying? | why |
|---|---|---|
| You have a contact list but send the same email to everyone | Yes | Segmentation is the first step and it costs little |
| You have a CRM but no active automated workflows | Yes | Almost all the potential is still untapped |
| You run paid campaigns but don't nurture leads after the click | Yes | You're paying for contacts that then go cold |
| You already have active automations but conversion rates are low | Yes | You need an audit of segmentation and timing |
| You don't have a structured contact list yet | No, for now | Build the base first, then automate |
What did the company that multiplied qualified leads by 9 actually do?
Three precise moves: segment contacts by real behavior, activate email sequences timed for the right moment, and measure only qualified leads, not every contact collected.
The HubSpot case starts from 12 qualified leads a month. The goal was to grow without increasing the budget. The team stopped treating all contacts the same and built three distinct segments: those who had just discovered the brand, those actively evaluating, and those ready to buy.
For each segment, it activated a different email sequence, with content and timing tailored to it. The result: 108 qualified leads a month within a few months. Not more contacts overall, but more ready contacts.
| Contact stage | Content sent | Goal |
|---|---|---|
| Discovery (just subscribed) | Educational content, no direct offer | Build trust and recognition |
| Evaluation (opened 2+ emails) | Case studies, comparisons, social proof | Reduce objections |
| Decision (visited pricing or product page) | Offer, demo, sales contact | Convert into a qualified lead |
| Inactive (hasn't opened in 60+ days) | Re-engagement email or list cleanup | Win back or remove to maintain quality |
Why do automated emails work so much better than manual ones?
They arrive at the right time, to people who have already shown interest. It's not magic: it's relevance. A relevant message at the right moment converts far better than a newsletter sent to the whole list.
The numbers are clear. According to Omnisend (via Sender.net), in 2025 automated emails accounted for just 2% of all sends but generated 30% of total email revenue. That's about 16 times higher return per send than manual campaigns.
The reason is simple: an automated email goes out when the contact does something, like visiting a page, downloading a document or abandoning a cart. Not when the marketing manager finds the time to hit "send."
What does this mean in practice for an Italian company that wants to replicate it?
Three concrete things: build segments based on real behavior, set up at least three automated workflows, and measure qualified leads, not email opens.
In Italy, the picture is clear: according to the Magnews Dossier 2025 (an analysis of nearly 4 billion emails), campaigns sent to small, well-profiled segments generate up to four times more engagement than mass sends. The problem is that most SMEs still do the opposite: a single send to the whole list, every week or every month.
Teams running paid campaigns, on Google Ads or Meta for example, often focus on the click and forget what happens next. As our analysis of Google Ads and the learning period also explains, optimizing only the acquisition phase without taking care of nurturing (the journey that turns a contact into a customer) is a costly mistake.
- 1 · Marketing managerSegment your list by behaviorSplit your contacts into at least three groups: new subscribers, recently engaged contacts, and those inactive for over 60 days.
- 2 · Marketing managerLaunch a welcome workflowA sequence of 3-5 emails over the first 14 days: introduce the brand, offer value, don't sell right away.
- 3 · Marketing manager / CRMSet up behavioral triggersSend an automatic email when a contact visits the pricing page, downloads a document or abandons a form.
- 4 · Marketing managerMeasure only qualified leadsDefine in advance what "qualified lead" means for your company. Don't count opens: what counts are contact or demo requests.
- 5 · Sales teamPass hot leads to salesWhen a contact reaches a threshold score (lead scoring), the CRM automatically alerts the sales rep.
Three real-world scenarios: what could it be worth for an Italian company?
The numbers vary by industry and starting list, but the mechanism is the same. Here are three illustrative examples built on the playbook.
Illustrative examples: the numbers show how the mechanism works and are not real client data.
Let's picture three typical Italian companies: a B2B consulting firm, an e-commerce store for industrial components and a network of real estate agencies. All three have a contact list and already run a few email campaigns, but have no structured automated workflows.
| Company type | Starting situation | After segmentation + automation | Main lever |
|---|---|---|---|
| B2B consulting firm | Monthly newsletter to 800 contacts, 8 leads/month | Stage-based workflow + trigger on services page → estimated 30-40 leads/month | Timing: the right email at the right moment in the evaluation journey |
| Components e-commerce | Promotions to the whole list, 2% conversion | Segments by purchased category + abandoned cart → estimated +60% email revenue | Pertinence: the right product for the right customer |
| Real estate agency network | Mass send to 5,000 contacts, low open rate | Segments by area + search stage → estimated open rate from 13% to 22% | Relevance: local, personalized content |
Which tools do you need, and how do they compare?
You don't need an enterprise tool. You need one that supports behavioral segmentation, automated workflows and CRM integration. Here are the main options for an SME.
Choosing a tool depends on your list size, your budget and how much your team is willing to learn. HubSpot has also published a detailed comparison of Pardot alternatives for B2B and a guide to enterprise automation, both useful if you're considering a platform switch.
For an Italian SME, the priority isn't the most powerful tool: it's the one your team actually uses. A tool set up to use 20% of its features delivers fewer results than a simpler tool used at 100%.
| Tool | Suitable for | Strengths | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| HubSpot (Starter/Pro plan) | SMEs with an integrated CRM | Visual workflows, lead scoring, native CRM | Cost grows with contacts |
| Mailchimp / Brevo | SMEs with a list of up to 10k contacts | Easy to use, low cost | Less advanced automations |
| ActiveCampaign | B2B SMEs with a sales pipeline | Powerful automations, lightweight built-in CRM | Medium learning curve |
| Klaviyo | E-commerce | Advanced segmentation on purchase data | Built almost exclusively for e-commerce |
Why it's in the spotlight now: is the Italian market really changing?
Yes. The cost of acquiring a B2B lead has doubled in three years, and 68% of Italian SMEs report a lead generation problem. If you don't optimize your existing funnel, you pay more for the same results.
According to the Osservatorio B2B of Politecnico di Milano, in 2026 68% of Italian B2B SMEs report having a lead generation problem. Pipelines have dried up and the cost of acquiring a contact has doubled in three years.
On the automation front, data from the Intelligent Business Process Automation Observatory of Politecnico di Milano (March 2026) shows that 62% of large Italian companies use at least one automation technology, but only 8% have adopted it at scale. For SMEs, the gap is even wider.
If you're already running paid campaigns, as described in our analysis of how to redistribute your budget when searches decline, you know the pressure on acquisition costs is real. Nurturing automation is one of the few levers that doesn't require extra budget.

Where do you actually start, step by step?
Start with an audit of your existing list, not with buying a new tool. 90% of the value is already in the list you have: you just need to stop treating it as one single block.
The first mistake is buying a new tool before understanding what isn't working in the one you already have. The audit comes first. Even if you use simple tools like Brevo or Mailchimp, you can implement most of this playbook without changing platform.
A practical guide to automated email segmentation is available right on the HubSpot blog, with setup examples for the main tools.
- 1 · Step 1List auditHow many contacts do you have? How many are active (opened at least one email in the last 90 days)? How many are inactive? Start here.
- 2 · Step 2Define your segmentsAt least three: new (last 30 days), active, inactive. If you have purchase or browsing data, add a "hot" segment.
- 3 · Step 3Build the welcome workflow3 emails in 14 days for new subscribers. Email 1: welcome and value. Email 2: a concrete case or social proof. Email 3: a light call to action.
- 4 · Step 4Activate behavioral triggersPricing page visit, document download, abandoned form: each one fires an automatic email within 1-2 hours.
- 5 · Step 5Set up lead scoringAssign a score to each action (open = 1 point, click = 3 points, product page visit = 5 points). Above a threshold, the lead goes to sales.
- 6 · Step 6Measure and optimize every 30 daysLook only at the qualified leads you generate, not at open rates. If a segment isn't converting, change the content or the timing, not the list.
What are the most common mistakes that block results?
The most common one is tracking open rates instead of qualified leads. The second is automating without segmenting: sending the same sequence to every contact isn't automation, it's scheduled spam.
If you run paid campaigns, you know the problem of budget wasted on audiences that aren't ready. The same goes for email: automating without segmenting just speeds up a process that wasn't working before. It's also worth reading our analysis of Reddit lead gen ads and the HubSpot integration to see how audience quality upstream affects the whole funnel downstream.
| Error | Why it blocks results | How to fix it |
|---|---|---|
| Using email open rates as the main KPI | Opens don't pay the bills: conversions do | Set qualified leads and contact requests as your KPIs |
| Automating without segmenting | Same email to everyone = low relevance = low conversion | Create at least 3 segments before activating any workflow |
| Workflows that are too aggressive (an email every 2 days) | They increase unsubscribes and hurt deliverability | Leave at least 4-7 days between emails in the early stage |
| Not cleaning the inactive list | Inactive contacts drag down open rates and damage your sender reputation | Every 90 days: run a reactivation campaign, then remove anyone who doesn't respond |
| Buying a new tool without an audit | The problem is often the strategy, not the tool | Audit first, then switch platforms if needed |
How do you know if it's really working?
Three indicators are enough to tell whether the playbook is delivering: qualified leads per month, conversion rate by segment, and cost per qualified lead. Everything else is noise.
The risk is drowning in data. Opens, clicks, unsubscribes, bounce rate: they're all useful for diagnosing technical issues, but they don't tell you whether the business is growing. The only number that really matters is how many qualified leads enter your CRM each month, and at what cost.
If you also manage paid campaigns, comparing cost per lead from paid with cost per lead from email automation is often eye-opening: the latter is almost always much lower, because it works with contacts you've already acquired.
| Indicator | What it measures | Alert threshold | Check frequency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qualified leads/month | The playbook's end result | If it doesn't grow after 60 days, review your segmentation | Monthly |
| Conversion rate by segment | Which segment converts best | Below 0.5%: a content or timing problem | Monthly |
| Cost per qualified lead | Efficiency compared to paid | If it exceeds the cost from paid, review the workflow | Quarterly |
| Open rate by segment | Quality of the email subject line and the list | Below 13% (Italian average, 2025): a subject line or deliverability problem | Monthly |
| Unsubscribe rate | A sign of excessive pressure or low relevance | Above 0.5%: too frequent or irrelevant content | Monthly |

So, is marketing automation worth investing in for your company?
It's worth it if you already have an active contact list and run paid or inbound campaigns, but have no structured automated workflows. The untapped potential is high and the cost of implementation is low.
Somewhere in between: you have a few automations running but have never segmented by behavior. An audit and a reconfiguration can improve results without changing tools.
Not yet if you don't have a structured contact list or a CRM yet. Build your acquisition base first, then automate nurturing.
How we see it at SHM
For us, marketing automation isn't a shortcut: it's how you give time back to your team and stop wasting budget on contacts who aren't ready. We believe technology should free people from routine — sending the same email to everyone every week is routine, not strategy.
We've worked on segmentation and funnel optimization projects in very different contexts: from industrial components to e-commerce, including B2B consulting. In every case, the starting point wasn't the tool but the question: who are your contacts and what are they looking for right now? Only then do you set up the automation.
Picture a manufacturing company with 2,000 contacts in its CRM, no active workflows and a salesperson manually chasing every request. A segmentation audit and three behavioral workflows — welcome, product interest, quote request — can radically change the team's workload without increasing ad spend. This is the kind of work we do.
If you want to figure out where to start, you can explore our approach to strategic AI integration, paid media on Google Ads and data processing and business intelligence. Or write to us directly: an hour of conversation is worth more than a thousand articles.
Frequently Asked Questions
The first signals show up within 30-45 days: open rate and click rate improve right after segmentation. Qualified leads grow steadily after 60-90 days, once the workflows have gathered enough data to optimize themselves. Don't expect significant results before two months.
Not necessarily a full CRM, but you need at least a tool that lets you segment contacts by behavior and trigger automated emails. Tools like ActiveCampaign or HubSpot Starter already include these features at prices an SME can afford.
It depends on the funnel stage. In the welcome phase (first 14 days), 3-4 emails are fine. In regular nurturing, 4-6 emails a month is a sustainable frequency. The sign you're overdoing it is an unsubscribe rate above 0.5%.
A qualified lead is a contact who has shown real interest and has the right profile to become a customer. In practice: they visited the pricing or product page, filled out a contact form, or reached a threshold score in lead scoring. The definition must be set before you activate any automation, otherwise you end up measuring different things every month.
Yes, with a few differences. For e-commerce, the most powerful triggers are abandoned cart, category browsing and post-purchase. For physical B2B products (components, machinery), the sales cycle is longer and nurturing needs to be more educational. The principle — right message, right person, right moment — is the same.
For an SME with lists of up to 10,000 contacts, manual segmentation by behavior (opens, clicks, visits) is already very effective. Predictive AI — which anticipates who is ready to buy before they show it explicitly — delivers a measurable advantage on larger lists: a Splio study of 340 brands found a 2.8% click rate with predictive AI versus 1.4% with manual segmentation.
It's not about tools: it's about no longer treating your list as one big block and starting to talk to people at the moment they're ready to listen.
Related articles
Discover more articles exploring similar topics, selected to offer you a more complete and stimulating perspective. Each piece of content is carefully chosen to enrich your experience.