- Is it really worth measuring my brand's AI visibility against competitors?
- What has really happened in the AI search market?
- What changes for my site when a Google AI Overview appears?
- What exactly is AEO benchmarking, and how does it work?
- How it works in practice: the steps to start AEO benchmarking
- Three real-world scenarios: what changes for an e-commerce store, a professional firm and a manufacturer?
- What tools are available for AEO benchmarking?
- What risks should I manage when I start AEO benchmarking?
- Why everyone's talking about it now: is the AI search market really relevant for Italian companies?
- What are the most common mistakes when starting AEO benchmarking?
- How do I know if AEO benchmarking is delivering results?
- Is AEO benchmarking worth it for your company?
- How we see it at SHM
- Frequently Asked Questions
- AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) benchmarking measures your brand's visibility in AI answers compared with competitors, separating market shifts from the effects of your own actions.
- Without comparative data, you can't tell whether a drop in visibility comes from a wrong choice of yours or from a movement across the whole industry.
- Market data shows that traffic from AI platforms has grown 527% year over year: ignoring this channel means giving ground to your competitors.
- With a structured process in just a few steps, even an SME can start monitoring its presence on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity without expensive tools.
Today, 51% of B2B buyers start their supplier research directly in an AI chatbot, according to the G2 "Answer Economy" 2026 report. If you don't know where you stand against your competitors in those answers, you're navigating without a compass.
Is it really worth measuring my brand's AI visibility against competitors?
Yes, and it's not something only large companies can do: without a comparison against the market, any data on your AI visibility is meaningless.
AEO benchmarking, where AEO stands for Answer Engine Optimization, meaning optimization for engines that answer in natural language like ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews, is not an academic exercise. It's the tool that helps you answer one concrete question: does my brand appear in AI answers more or less than my competitors?
Without this comparison, a 20% drop in AI citations could mean you got your strategy wrong, or simply that the entire market lost visibility in that period. The difference is huge when you have to justify an investment to management.
| Your situation | Is AEO benchmarking worth it? | why |
|---|---|---|
| You already have an active SEO strategy | Yes | You can tell whether your optimizations are working in AI search too |
| You're considering new investments in visibility | Yes | Comparative data justifies the budget in front of leadership |
| Your competitors are active online | Yes | Without a comparison, you don't know whether you're losing or gaining ground |
| You have a limited marketing budget | Yes | Benchmarking shows you where to focus resources for the most impact |
| You don't have a structured digital presence yet | Build the foundations first | Benchmarking is only useful if you have content to optimize |
What has really happened in the AI search market?
Traffic from AI platforms grew 527% in one year, and ChatGPT alone now generates almost three quarters of all AI referral traffic to websites.
To see why AEO benchmarking has become urgent, just look at the market numbers. Google AI Overviews, the automatic answer box that appears at the top of search results, passed 2.5 billion monthly active users in May 2026, according to the Google I/O 2026 keynote reported by Digiday.
Meanwhile, referral traffic from AI platforms grew 527% year over year between 2024 and 2025, according to The Stacc / Search Engine Land. This isn't a niche trend: it's the fastest-growing traffic source on the web.
AI traffic isn't evenly distributed. ChatGPT dominates with almost 75% of total AI referral traffic, but the market is fragmenting: in B2B, ChatGPT's share fell from 89% in August 2025 to 63% in April 2026, while Perplexity more than doubled, according to Goodie AI. That means tracking only ChatGPT is no longer enough.
What changes for my site when a Google AI Overview appears?
When Google shows an AI Overview, clicks on traditional organic results nearly halve: they drop from 15% to 8%, a relative decline of 47%.
This finding, from the Pew Research Center based on 68,879 real searches by 900 U.S. adults, changes how you need to think about online visibility. Ranking on page one of Google is no longer enough: if you aren't cited in the AI Overview, you may be invisible to almost half of the users who would have clicked on your site.
Organic CTR (the click-through rate on search results) on queries with an AI Overview fell from 1.76% to 0.61% between June 2024 and September 2025, a 61% drop, across a sample of 25 million impressions, according to Seer Interactive via Visible Authority. You can dig deeper into the impact of this trend in our article on AI Overviews and brands: what changes for your visibility.
The point isn't to panic, but to understand that the game has changed. As we explain in our analysis of the 7 AI search myths debunked by real data, AI visibility doesn't replace traditional SEO: it works alongside it, with different rules.
What exactly is AEO benchmarking, and how does it work?
AEO benchmarking measures how often your brand is cited in AI answers compared to your competitors, across a defined set of questions relevant to your industry.
In practice, you ask AI platforms (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini) a series of questions your potential customers would really ask, such as “Who are the best industrial equipment suppliers in Italy?” or “What software should I use to manage warehouse logistics?”, and systematically record who gets cited and how often.
The value of benchmarking lies in comparison over time and against competitors. A single citation figure tells you nothing: if your brand appears in 30% of answers, that's a great result if the market leader is at 25%, and a warning sign if they're at 60%.
| Benchmark component | What it measures | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Citation frequency | How often the brand appears in AI answers across a set of queries | Shows absolute presence in the AI conversation |
| AI share of voice | Share of the brand's citations out of all citations in the industry | Enables direct comparison with competitors |
| Position in the answer | Whether the brand is cited first, in the middle or at the end | The first citations get more user attention |
| Citation sentiment | Whether the brand is cited positively, neutrally or negatively | A brand cited negatively can do more harm than good |
| Coverage by platform | How your presence varies across ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity | The AI market is fragmented: each platform has its own audience |
How it works in practice: the steps to start AEO benchmarking
You start by defining the right questions, then collect data systematically and build a comparison with your competitors over time.
- 1 · Marketing managerDefine your reference queriesCollect 20-50 questions your customers would ask an AI chatbot when searching for a supplier. Group them into categories: problem to solve, comparison of solutions, brand search.
- 2 · Marketing manager / agencyIdentify the competitors to monitorChoose 3-5 direct competitors. Add 1-2 players you see as industry references, even if they're bigger than you.
- 3 · Team or dedicated toolCollect AI answers systematicallyAsk the same questions on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. Record who gets cited, in which position and with what tone. Repeat every 2-4 weeks.
- 4 · Marketing managerCalculate your AI share of voiceDivide your brand's citations by the total citations of all monitored brands. This is your starting point for measuring progress.
- 5 · Marketing manager / leadershipPresent the comparative data to managementUse the comparison with competitors to put every change in context. A 10% drop is irrelevant if the market fell 15%; it's critical if your competitors grew.
To learn more about earning citations and measuring AI visibility in a structured way, read our guide on AI Answers: how to earn citations and measure visibility.
Three real-world scenarios: what changes for an e-commerce store, a professional firm and a manufacturer?
AEO benchmarking suits any type of company: the set of questions changes, not the method.
Illustrative examples: numbers are meant to show the reasoning, they are not real customer data.
| Company type | Typical queries to monitor | What it looks for in the benchmark | Action if you're behind competitors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clothing e-commerce | "Where can I buy sustainable winter jackets online?" | Citation frequency on category queries | Strengthen content on sustainability and materials |
| Tax consulting firm | "Which accountant should I choose for an SME with export activity?" | Presence in answers to local industry questions | Publish practical guides on specific tax topics |
| Industrial components manufacturer | "Which centrifugal pump suppliers are there in Italy?" | Share of voice versus international competitors | Optimize product pages and technical case studies |
What tools are available for AEO benchmarking?
There are solutions at different levels of cost and complexity, from free manual approaches to specialized platforms.
| Approach | How it works | Indicative cost | Suitable for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manual with spreadsheet | Queries entered by hand on ChatGPT/Gemini/Perplexity, results logged in Excel | Internal time only | SMEs with a limited budget, early stage |
| Advanced SEO tools (e.g. Semrush, Ahrefs) | Some modules are starting to track AI presence, integrated with classic SEO data | From ~€100/month | Companies already subscribed to SEO suites |
| Specialized AEO platforms (e.g. Peec, Profound) | Automatic monitoring of AI citations at scale, with competitor comparison | From ~€500/month | Mid-market companies needing structured reporting |
| Specialized agency | Audit and managed monitoring, with reporting for leadership | Variable | Those who want ready-to-use data without managing it in-house |
To understand how the market for AI monitoring tools is evolving, read our deep dive on Peec and the race for AI search visibility.
What risks should I manage when I start AEO benchmarking?
The main risk is measuring the wrong things or interpreting data without context, leading to decisions that make things worse.
A common mistake is optimizing to be cited at all costs, without checking the context of the citation. A brand cited as an “example of what to avoid” is worse off than a brand that isn't cited at all. Citation sentiment is an integral part of the benchmark.
A second risk involves conflicting information: if ChatGPT describes your brand differently from Gemini, you have a consistency problem in the sources that feed the AIs. You can explore this topic in our article on conflicting brand information and the AI search risk.
| Risk | How it shows up | How it's managed |
|---|---|---|
| Negative citations | The brand appears in AI answers, but in a critical light | Monitor sentiment, not just frequency |
| Inconsistent data across platforms | ChatGPT says one thing about your brand, Gemini says another | Audit the sources that feed AI (Wikipedia, press releases, reviews) |
| Benchmarking irrelevant queries | You measure questions customers don't actually ask | Validate the query set with real search data (Google Search Console) |
| Mistaking market shifts for your own mistakes | You change strategy over a drop affecting the whole industry | Always compare your data with competitors' data over the same period |
Why everyone's talking about it now: is the AI search market really relevant for Italian companies?
Yes: AI's presence in search has grown quickly and steadily, and B2B buyer behavior is shifting toward chatbots as the first point of contact.
The presence of Google AI Overviews on search queries grew from 6.49% in January 2025 to a peak of 24.61% in July 2025, then settled at 15.69% in November 2025, based on a sample of over 10 million keywords tracked by Semrush, according to SEOProfy. It's not a passing spike: it's the new normal.
For Italian B2B companies, the most relevant finding comes from the G2 “Answer Economy” 2026 report, cited by Loudspeaker Marketing: 51% of B2B software buyers start their vendor research directly in an AI chatbot, up from 29% in April 2025. In less than a year, the share has nearly doubled.

What are the most common mistakes when starting AEO benchmarking?
The most common mistake is starting to measure without a competitive benchmark, which makes the data useless for strategic decisions.
Here are the five mistakes we see most often, even among companies already well established digitally:
- Measuring only your own brand without comparing it to competitors: absolute numbers don't tell you whether you're doing well or badly.
- Using a query set that's too generic: questions like "Who is the best supplier?" don't reflect how customers really search.
- Running a single measurement instead of monitoring over time: AI models update their answers constantly.
- Ignoring smaller platforms: Perplexity and Claude are growing fast, especially in B2B.
- Not linking AEO data to your content strategy: a benchmark is only useful if it leads to concrete actions on what to publish and how to structure it.
How do I know if AEO benchmarking is delivering results?
Track your AI share of voice over time and compare it with your competitors': it's the only indicator that tells you whether you're gaining or losing ground.
| Indicator | How it is measured | Positive signal | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI share of voice | Brand citations / total industry citations | Grows or holds steady against competitors | Drops while competitors grow |
| Citation frequency | No. of AI answers citing the brand out of total queries monitored | Exceeds 30-40% of category queries | Below 10% on queries where you're the market leader |
| Average position in the answer | First, second or third citation in the AI answer | The brand appears among the top two | The brand is always last or absent |
| Consistency across platforms | The same brand described similarly on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity | Consistent, positive descriptions | Contradictory or negative information |
| Referral traffic from AI | Sessions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, etc. in Google Analytics | Grows month over month | Flat or declining while the market grows |
To connect this data to your analytics system, read our deep dive on how to turn Google's AI report into useful business data. You can find more articles on this topic in our hub dedicated to SEO and AI visibility.

Is AEO benchmarking worth it for your company?
It's worth it if you already have an active digital presence, operate in a competitive market and want to justify your AI search budget to leadership with data. Even an SME with limited resources can start with a manual approach and build structure over time.
Somewhere in between: you're in the middle of building your digital presence. Start with a manual benchmark on 10-15 key queries, so that when you have content to optimize you'll already have a starting point.
Not yet if you don't have published content or a basic SEO strategy yet: the benchmark measures something that doesn't exist. Build the foundations first, then measure.
How we see it at SHM
For us, AEO benchmarking is first and foremost a tool for clarity. We believe AI should be integrated to free companies from routine and give time back to the decisions that really matter, and measuring AI visibility with comparative data is exactly that: removing ambiguity and putting numbers on the table that let you choose.
We've worked with manufacturing and consulting companies that had already invested in SEO but didn't know whether that investment was also paying off in AI search. The starting point is always the same: define the right queries, build a set of relevant competitors and start collecting data systematically. Only then can you talk about optimization.
If you want to know where your brand stands in AI answers compared to your competitors, our SEO for AI service is the place to start. For those who want to fold this data into a broader monitoring system, we also work on data processing and business intelligence and on strategic AI integration to link AI visibility to business goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
AEO benchmarking measures how often your brand is cited in answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, compared to your competitors. Unlike traditional SEO, which measures rankings in search results, AEO measures presence in natural-language answers, where there is no visible ranking, only a citation or the lack of one.
With a manual approach, 2-3 days are enough to define the query set, identify competitors and run the first measurement. The value of the benchmark grows over time, with repeated measurements every 2-4 weeks: the first snapshot is a starting point, not a final result.
ChatGPT generates almost 75% of total AI referral traffic, but in B2B its share dropped significantly between 2025 and 2026, while Perplexity and Gemini are growing. Monitoring at least three platforms (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity) gives you a more reliable picture and lets you spot trends before they become obvious.
Comparing against competitors is the key: showing that your brand appears in 20% of AI answers while your main competitor is at 45% is a concrete argument for investing. Market data, like the 527% growth in AI traffic or the 51% of B2B buyers who start their research in a chatbot, provides the context to explain why this channel is a priority.
It's especially useful for SMEs, because it shows where to focus limited resources. A company with a small budget can't optimize everything: the benchmark shows which queries and platforms have the greatest competitive impact, so you don't spread your energy too thin.
A negative mention can do more damage than no mention at all, because it reaches users who are already evaluating their options. The first step is to identify the sources feeding that description (reviews, articles, forums) and work on correcting them or strengthening the positive ones. Sentiment monitoring is an integral part of a complete AEO benchmarking process.
The winner isn't the brand that appears most often in AI answers. It's the one that appears at the right moment, with the right message, and knows how to measure it.
Related articles
Discover more articles exploring similar topics, selected to offer you a more complete and stimulating perspective. Each piece of content is carefully chosen to enrich your experience.