- The context: what triggered the FTC lawsuit against Amazon
- The numbers that matter: Amazon Ads in the retail landscape
- The strategic view: what it means if you manage budgets on third-party platforms
- The European regulatory front: what changes for Italian retailers
- Operational implications: how to rethink your budget allocation
- What nobody talks about: the problem of algorithmic trust
- Outlook: what to expect in 2027
The FTC and 22 U.S. states have taken legal action against Amazon. The charge is serious: the company allegedly applied hidden surcharges to advertising, hurting the businesses that invest on the platform. So this isn't just a story about the U.S. market.
In fact, many Italian retailers and SMEs in e-commerce allocate significant budgets to Amazon Ads. As a result, an opaque fee structure, if confirmed, raises serious questions about the transparency of advertising costs. It also puts a spotlight on a broader issue: depending on third-party platforms to distribute your media spend.
In this article, we at SHM Studio look at the regulatory context, the numbers that matter if you run retail campaigns, and the operational implications for a more resilient advertising strategy. In short, the Amazon-FTC case is a signal no one planning digital advertising investments in 2026 should ignore, with an eye on 2027.
The context: what triggered the FTC lawsuit against Amazon
On August 31, 2026, the Federal Trade Commission filed a new lawsuit against Amazon. The complaint, backed by 22 U.S. states, alleges that Amazon applied an undisclosed advertising surcharge to third-party sellers. In essence, Amazon allegedly inflated ad costs without clearly telling advertisers. The story is covered in detail by TechCrunch.
This isn't the first clash between the FTC and the Seattle giant. But this case stands out for its specific focus: not data handling or anticompetitive practices in general, but the fee structure of the advertising system. So the potential impact lands directly on anyone investing in Amazon Ads.
For Italian marketing leaders, this is far from abstract. Many SMEs and mid-market retailers allocate a sizable share of their digital budget to Amazon. That's why understanding what's happening is essential to making informed decisions.
The numbers that matter: Amazon Ads in the retail landscape
Amazon has become the world's third-largest digital advertising platform. According to industry data, Amazon's advertising segment has passed $50 billion in annual revenue. In Italy, the share of retailers using Amazon as their primary sales channel, and therefore their primary advertising channel, has grown steadily in recent years.
Amazon Ads also runs on automated auctions and optimization algorithms. That makes it hard for the average advertiser to independently check whether the cost paid matches the actual value of the auction. So a hidden surcharge structure, if confirmed, would be structurally invisible without specific audits.
It's also worth remembering that the FTC has already investigated Amazon's self-preferencing practices in organic results. This new lawsuit extends regulatory scrutiny to the ads system. In particular, algorithmic transparency is at the center of the regulatory debate in both the U.S. and Europe, as the European Digital Markets Act shows.
The strategic view: what it means if you manage budgets on third-party platforms
The Amazon-FTC case raises a broader question. If you entrust your ad spend to a single closed platform, you implicitly accept a degree of opacity. Yet this risk is often underestimated in media planning.
In fact, programmatic advertising systems and proprietary platforms, from Amazon to Meta to Google, run on auction logic that advertisers can't fully verify. As a result, the actual cost per acquisition can differ significantly from what you expected. At SHM Studio, this is something we address systematically with clients during campaign audits.
The risk isn't only financial, either. Relying too heavily on a single platform exposes your brand to regulatory volatility, sudden algorithm changes and, as in the Amazon case, potential cost reclassifications following regulatory investigations. So diversifying your media mix isn't just good practice: it's a resilience measure.
Concentrating on a single platform amplifies both the peaks and the risks.
The European regulatory front: what changes for Italian retailers
The U.S. lawsuit has direct implications for Europe too. The Digital Markets Act, in force since 2024, requires gatekeepers, Amazon among them, to be transparent about their advertising practices. So a ruling against Amazon in the U.S. could speed up similar investigations by the European Commission.
The Italian Competition Authority (AGCM) has also opened proceedings against Amazon in the past over unfair commercial practices. As a result, the regulatory framework for Italian retailers selling on Amazon could evolve quickly over the next 12-18 months.
For marketing leaders, this means one concrete thing: now is the right time to review your platform contracts, analyze spend reports in more granular detail and assess whether the transparency you get is adequate. In particular, we recommend requesting detailed cost breakdowns by placement type and comparing them with market benchmarks.
Operational implications: how to rethink your budget allocation
The news shouldn't trigger knee-jerk reactions. Dropping Amazon Ads overnight makes no sense if a significant share of your sales depends on the platform. But it is time to start a structured review.
Here are a few concrete actions marketing teams can start in the short term.
- Amazon Ads spend audit: analyze cost reports by campaign, compare actual CPC with category benchmarks and check that reported spend lines up with recorded conversions.
- Media mix diversification: consider increasing your share on alternative channels, such as Google Ads and LinkedIn Ads, depending on your target and industry.
- Investment in owned channels: strengthening your presence on assets you own, such as your website, SEO and email marketing, reduces reliance on third-party platforms. In this sense, a solid SEO strategy is a long-term asset.
- Regulatory monitoring: follow the FTC proceedings and any European investigations to anticipate changes in platforms' contractual terms.
You should also consider adopting AI applied to marketing tools to automatically monitor performance and flag anomalies in advertising costs. Likewise, a data-driven approach to your digital marketing strategy helps you spot signs of inefficient spend faster.
What nobody talks about: the problem of algorithmic trust
There's one aspect that rarely comes up in industry analyses. Most advertisers accept platform logic without verifying it. This isn't a technical skills problem: it's a structural problem of information asymmetry.
Advertising platforms are closed systems. Advertisers see the results, but not the mechanism. As a result, any surcharges or algorithmic inefficiencies stay invisible until they surface in court, as in the Amazon case. So algorithmic trust can't be blind: it has to be verified regularly through independent audits.
That's why we at SHM Studio recommend that clients review their campaigns every quarter, paying particular attention to the match between reported investment and measurable results. A structured approach to digital marketing management always includes this control step.
Finally, it's worth remembering that transparency isn't just an ethical issue. It's a competitive advantage. If you truly understand where your advertising budget goes, you can optimize more effectively and react faster to market changes. To dive deeper into these topics, the team at SHM Studio is available for a consultation. You'll find more resources and analysis on our blog.
Outlook: what to expect in 2027
The FTC proceeding will take a long time. The regulatory impact, however, could come sooner. In Europe, the Commission could open parallel investigations by the end of 2026. Other players in the sector, such as Meta and Google, could also face similar scrutiny over the transparency of advertising costs.
For Italian retailers, 2027 is shaping up to be a year of transition. The rules of the game on ad platforms could change significantly. As a result, those who start building a more balanced media mix today, with a solid SEO and content component, diversified campaigns and owned assets, will be in a stronger position. Likewise, investing in a deep understanding of your own marketing data is a priority that can't wait. For a complete overview of the digital services available, the starting point is always an analysis of your specific context.
Related articles
Discover more articles exploring similar topics, selected to offer you a more complete and stimulating perspective. Each piece of content is carefully chosen to enrich your experience.